Why European Union would fail ! Historical, cultural and political aspects
Robert Schuman, French
foreign minister in cooperation with Jean Monnet drew up the internationally
renowned Schuman Plan, which he published on 9 May 1950, the date now regarded
as the birth of the European Union. Since
crusades, Europe has been attempting an union with a aim of ending the frequent
and bloody wars among neighbor-nations. The management of the EU crisis makes
you wonder at the direction of the European Union and whether they have been
losing sight of the best way to promote European integration.
Looking back, the period
5th Century (fall of the Roman Empire) to 999AD, have been termed
‘The Dark Ages of Europe’, a period of indigence, hunger and insecurity. Even,
the crusades were perceived as a defensive act against the flourishing Muslim
state, which Europe (Christians) perceived as a threat to their faith and their
way of life. Hence, in Enlightenment era too, the scholars recognized European
way as a joint inheritance of Christian era and Classical era. The Classical
world of the Greeks, with a regularity in nature and its governing principle,
the reasoning mind, and that of the Romans, who adopted Hellenic culture
contributing a new order, style, laws. However, church and civil law were the
heart of the crisis which required critical examination of Christian faith, its
foundations in the Bible, and the authority embodied in the church. In last stages of holy war, a section of
Crusaders aimed not so much at toppling Muslim forces in the Holy Land but at
combating any and all of those seen as enemies of the Christian faith.
Overall, the crusades
were a military failure. To the Muslims, they were just one more annoying
barbarian invasion, not nearly as much of a threat as the Mongols were later.
The combination of cultures resulted in the invention of the windmill, the
compass, gunpowder, and clocks. Scholarly exchange took place. In middle-ages,
slowly and obscurely, amid stupidity and ignorance, nations and languages of
Europe were being forged. The Renaissance was the first act, the Reformation
the second, the Revolution the third, and finally nations of the present have
been evolving in the establishment of the democratic idea.
According to Coon, Garn,
and Birdsell (1950), Cole (1965) and a number of other anthropologists, the
Europeans have been sub-divided into seven sub-races consisting of : 1 -
Mediterranean peoples of Spain, Italy, and southeast Europe. 2 - Alpine peoples
of France and central and southern Germany. 3 - Nordic peoples of England, the
east of Ireland, and Scotland, the Netherlands, Belgium and Northern Germany,
Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and Western Finland. 4 - Celtic peoples of Wales, the
west of Ireland, and the western highlands of Scotland. 5 - Dinaric peoples of
east-central Europe. 6 - Slavic peoples of northern Poland, the Baltic States,
and Russia west of the Urals. 7 - Basques of northern Spain and southwest
France. All these sub-races started a Europe-wide debate about the possible
model function that the Roman Empire had for Europe.
Hence, slowly and
steadily, the essential qualities were developed which distinguish the modern Europe
from the ancient and the mediaeval world. Initially, Italy created a new
spiritual atmosphere of culture and of intellectual freedom which has been the
life-breath of the European races. Whereas, Spain and England had started the
exploration and colonization of the world. At the same time, Germany achieved Reformation
of the labor almost single-handedly. France too collected, centralized, and
diffused intelligence with irresistible energy. On negative side, at that time,
the corruption of religious orders and cynical abuse of the fiscal machinery of
the church provoked a movement that at first demanded reform from within and
ultimately chose the path of separation. Thus, the religious tensions released
by the Reformation eventually pitted ideologies against each other; this in
turn initiated civil wars that lasted 30 years (in the case of France and
Germany) and even 80 years (in the Netherlands). Germany, France, and the
Netherlands each achieved a settlement of the religious problem by means of
war.
The period 1789–1815
have been defined by French Revolution and Napoleon. The period 1815–71 was
dominated by a new round of revolution and the unifications of the German and
Italian nations. But period 1871–1914, an age of imperialism, shaped new kind
of political debate and the pressure that culminated in war. Since 1871,
European states were increasingly locked in diplomatic interaction, culminating
in continent wide alliance systems. This lead to growing nationalism where
individual states jealously protected their identities.
Advancing
industrialization heightened competition among individual nations and created a
massive power disparity. Germany,
Britain, and France, beleaguered by growing socialist gains that frightened a
conservative leadership and intense popular nationalism, they accepted war not
only as a diplomatic tool but also as a means of countering internal disarray.
In colonial era, the
concept of a "Europeanization of the world" signifies the dilemma. On
one hand, there are positive achievements, such as modern statehood,
urbanization, rationalism and Christianity, European thought systems such as
Liberalism, Socialism and Positivism were received with great enthusiasm in
France, England, Brazil and Japan. On the other hand, there are negative
legacies, such as Caesarism, racism and colonial violence. Nowhere was the
ambivalence between ruthless hegemonic ambition and concepts such as world
citizenship, cosmopolitanism and human rights. Therefore, the European claim to
superiority legitimized the logic of unequal interrelationship between colonial
societies and a novel capitalism in Europe.
Nationalism had been a
feature of Europe since the French Revolution. Equally
powerful, and more deeply rooted in history, was Germanic nationalism . Two
global developments, moreover, formed an ominous backdrop to Europe’s
territorial disputes. One was the Russian Revolution of 1917, which inspired a
few idealists but mainly aroused fear throughout the rest of Europe. The other
was the active intervention of the United States playing a determinant role in
shaping the peace. The two wars, of 1914–18 and 1939–45, brought the old Europe
from balance of power to the brink of destruction. Europeans were thenceforth
spectators at or minor actors in the global balance of terror between the
United States and the U.S.S.R.
The EC was founded in response to a checkered half-century of
European history, when some of the world’s most civilized countries had plumbed
depths of savagery, folly, tyranny, and genocide that in a work of science
fiction would be hard to believe. The EC’s most obvious purpose had been to
reconcile former enemies and prevent war. Its second aim was to avoid the
economic errors Europeans had made in the 1930s, when, instead of collaborating
on a global recovery policy in response to the Great Depression, they worsened
the crisis through economic nationalism that was the breeding ground for
dictatorship. Moreover, Europe’s individual countries, once great powers, were
dwarfed numerically, politically, and militarily by the United States and the
Soviet Union. By the early 21st century the gigantic countries like India and
China had also become economic rivals for the European Union.
No comments:
Post a Comment